The right rental decision at John F. Kennedy International Airport depends on where the itinerary goes after pickup, not on a generic -best car- label. Start with the airport transfer, then list passengers, luggage, parking needs, road conditions, and any toll or charging questions.
A Manhattan-only stay often makes parking and toll exposure more important than vehicle size. A Long Island, Queens, or multi-borough itinerary changes the decision: compare luggage, child-seat needs, bridge and tunnel planning, and where the vehicle can realistically be parked.
Compare the agency's current vehicle description and terms with the actual route before booking. Treat rates, authorization holds, hours, inventory, and add-on policies as changeable: verify them with the operator and the relevant airport or transportation authority immediately before travel.